Swords Blog

New Reality Show Stars Earn Stripes Slammed By Veteran Group For ‘Trivializing War’

Share This Page Share This Page


stars-earn-stripes poster

Reality television has long been accused of pushing moral boundaries, and a new show from NBC that sends celebrities into mock military missions has caused outrage among veteran groups who know the grim reality of real-life combat.

“I was speechless when I first saw this. People have to realize that war is not a game,” Amy N. Fairweather, Director of Policy for Swords to Plowshares, told RadarOnline.com in an exclusive interview regarding the controversial show.

“The real warriors who go out there and come home from war don’t win a reality prize. They live with the consequences of being exposed to the dangerous elements they survived.”

In NBC’s latest Mark Burnett-produced venture that premieres on Monday, hosts Samantha Harris and retired General Wesley Clark send a motley band of stars — including Nick Lachey, Dean Cain and Laila Ali — to a remote training facility where they will be challenged to execute complicated missions inspired by real military exercises. Each contestant is to be paired with a military special operative, including former U.S. Army Delta Force and Green Berets, U.S. Navy SEALS, U.S. Marines and police officers.

“I was speechless when I first saw this. People have to realize that war is not a game”

“From helicopter drops into water to long-range weapons fire, the contestants will be tested physically, mentally and emotionally,” explains the show’s website.

While the cash prize they win will go to a veteran or military charity, the concept of the show is offensive to many of those who have fought on the front line.

“I think it is trivializing war, where the consequences are not that you are knocked out the competition next week, the consequences are you don’t get to go on with your life — period — or in your life as it was before as an able–bodied individual,” explained Fairweather.

“..when they get out there and it’s real, it’s not that cool anymore. It’s real blood, real dead comrades, and real children and civilians that you see in horrifying circumstances”

They show explosions in the show, how cool! But then most soldier’s experience with an explosion is debilitating injury or — as in J.R. Martinez’s case — severe burns, plus the psychological side effects of being wounded such as post traumatic stress disorder,” she told RadarOnline.com.

“I am sure the training is tough so the contestants may think they know how difficult it is and the hell soldiers go through, but that is nothing compared to the hell of war.”

Swords to Plowshares is a community-based non-profit that helps veterans deal with the physical, psychological and economic traumas they deal with coming back from war and trying to transition back into the civilian world.

Fairweather explained that many of the vets she meets joined up when they were 17 or 18 years old and thought video games and action movies were “pretty damn cool.”

“Then when they get out there and it’s real, it’s not that cool anymore. It’s real blood, real dead comrades, and real children and civilians that you see in horrifying circumstances,” she revealed.

The plight of veterans was highlighted last year when ABC cast Iraq war hero J.R. Martinez on Dancing with the Stars, but while he “is an individual who suffered horrific burns then had real achievements,” expressed Fairweather. “This is so cartoony. It is the total opposite of what he did.”

As for host General Wesley Clark, who had a highly acclaimed 34-year career in the Army and the Department of Defense during which he received many military decorations, knighthoods and a Presidential Medal of Freedom, she is shocked that he agreed to do the show.

“What was he thinking?” asked Fairweather.

Stars Earn Stripes premieres on NBC on Monday, August 13 at 9 pm.

Source: Radar Online, August 12, 2012, by Debbie Emery

Comments( 4 ) PRINT

4 Responses to New Reality Show Stars Earn Stripes Slammed By Veteran Group For ‘Trivializing War’

  1. Fredrick L. Nayes says:

    Ok. Everyone is attacking Stars Earn Stripes because they say it is Trivilizing war. Wait a minute. I do not hear or see anyone bitching and complaining about War Movies or War shown on TV! Those War Movies don’t get it accurate by a long shot. Those guys in those movies pretend to get shot and get up to start filming another show the following day or week or whatever and y’all are slamming this show?!? Get a life! Any money from this goes to helping out our veterans and our Military service members!

    • Rob Kane says:

      The problem is that it is a game show based on war. It’s portrayed as fun and games but the real life consequences are dire. This recruiting tool glorifies warfare while recruits are ill-prepared for the horrors of war. The few people that return home without PTSD, the better. War is not a game.

  2. Randi Masssengill says:

    There is one thing that they seem to be forgetting on this so called “show”, and that is the mental anguish that our men and women in uniform go through during war, and after. They can simulate a small portion of the physical side of war, but not much. Can they show one of the co-stars holding another in his/her arms, as one dies a slow painful death? NO, they can’t! Should a loved one, “at home” die, will NBC let the stars go home for the funeral? Yep, they sure will. If one of the male star’s wives goes into labor, will that male star get to be there for the birth of that baby,??? YOU BET he will. Our Military men and women don’t have that luxury! And how about the ones left at home, be at male or female? They are now a single parent trying on a meager salary to make ends meet. They worry when the doorbell rings, a knock at the door, and are terrified when an unknown car drives into the drive way! Those are just a FEW of the MENTAL parts of war that they will NEVER EVER be able to simulate, and mental is just as important as physical!

  3. Pingback: ‘Stars Earn Stripes’ Earns Negative Attention « Christiane Smedley

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>